The goals of both of these are different for a reason, because the French Revolution wanted a government and the American Revolution wanted to get away from their government. On July 14th, the Parisians responded by storming the royal prison, called the Bastille. I actually had a whole section on Democrats that, like, we just dont even have time to get to. The sphere of liberty in the US is broad enough to wear a variety of communities can live side by side with each other. View full question and answer details: https://www.wyzant.com/resources/answers/920758/compare-the-cause-and-outcomes-of-the-american-revolution-and-the-fren. I see this buildup of of, like, a different type of civil war, almost, where its, like, its not a civil war of fighting, its a civil war of works. We know that the media feeds it. Im so tough that I would watch Texas to secede or Tennessee or Georgia just a seed. Corrections? Divisions along racial, class, and ideological lines frequently led to violence. Because you do this thing at the beginning where everybody tells you, like, what they do for fun and, you know, where they live and what they did for work and, like, you know, just the sweetest room, she talks about your delicious grandchildren. You know what? The American and French revolutions are similar in some ways but different in others. Similar to the French, it also started because of wanting equality rights. But theyre not, like, mad about her. Copyright 2023 IPL.org All rights reserved. I was gonna say yes to both. British attempts to assert greater control over colonial affairs after a long period . Oh, if Democrats move into red states, they shouldnt be able to vote for at least five years. Maybe its both. American A "Reign of Terror" followed the revolution (American, French, or Both?) Yeah. The French Revolution was not successful in forming a democratic government due to Frances history of a monarchy, economic issues and divison among its people. Right? The goal of the American Revolution was to get away from the British government and be free. Right? But right now, Sarah, were still in the world where anybody who stands up. When the Enlightenment ideas went from France and beyond Europe they were found in books like Diderots Encyclopedia. Thats the exhausted majority. And they go far right, but same time, if theres something bad happening caused by the right, theyll call it out. But before I do that since you brought it up, I wanna hit this set. What the leader does is the leader sets the course of a cultural river. Malcolm F. Purinton is a part-time lecturer of world history and the history of modern Europe at Northeastern University and Emmanuel College in Boston. I do not like them. The American Revolution set the background for the modern nation state as well as molding the modern Army. Theyve just turd from white right wing media. And after January sixth, Trumps approval rating with Republicans stayed very high, very slight downslope, very slight. So some of it is this social signaling. Okay? In each location, there was a noticeable trend of mistreatment between government and people. The French was influenced by the American Revolution because they saw how successful it was and thought it would work for them, The French Revolution was almost an exact replica of the American Revolution. A less radical declaration of independence followed in 1821 through an alliance of rich Creole elites and more conservative clergy. Now theres been some gradual lessening on the left as well, but mainly on the right. However, there were also differences as far as political, economic and social causes were concerned. Shortly after that, in the 1700s there was the French Revolution. A new nation was born, but it was not entirely egalitarian. In the American colonies there was no set divisions of people and power, all social classes were equally affected by the government. And were having a great conversation and then she turns to me and she says, you know, they sent this tornado to punish the red states. This cross-curricular compare and contrast activity is perfect for the social studies or English classroom and takes about one hour.It includes the following:-A 3-page article about the causes, events, and outcomes American and French Revolutions . My father-in-law who just passed all the epic times. Their eyes are wide. And then it runs in to the new course of the river. Well, we just heard some of the the ways in which this happens. Because I Will Saletan is it is not a one-sided thing. it. These revolutions did not lead to long-lasting constitutional republics and were soon replaced by rulers who cared more about power than the liberal ideas that allowed them to rule in the first place and who ruled on the basis of populist politics, family networks, and military strength. They both had a time when both sides oppressed the French and British government. You know, I dont know. The American and French revolutions are similar in some ways but different in others. You and I are frequently on the same page about this. Jim Crow violated that social compact in the most dramatic of ways. First, Enlightenment ideas and ideals inspired all of them. When the king called the Estates General, the Third Estate suddenly had a voice. A goal of the French Revolution was that the third estate became eager to have an actual leader that would pay attention to their needs so they because the National Assembly and agreed on the tennis court oath. Right. So theres somebody else on the other side. And if the hypermagoworld keeps losing, then there can be a hope for a reassessment. Finally, they were connected by economic and political networks. I mean, its ridiculous the way its run right now. The French navy in particular played a key role in bringing about the British surrender at Yorktown, which effectively ended the war. The politicians feed it. And then number three, theres the question of identity. Thats right. I mean, this is where you get West Virginia, for example, East Tennessee. Since you wrote the book. And in fact, the dominion voting system that was the subject of an enormous amount of controversy, is a dramatic improvement over prior forms of voting. Fire the guy who called this race. Is that a collapse in the faith of institutions? They then read, analyze, and compare and contrast each country's national anthem, the Star Spangled Banner and La Marseillaise, by answering 14 questions of varying degrees of difficulty. Beginning with the Stamp Act of 1765, Great Britain tried and failed to raise revenue from their subjects in the American colonies. I. dont really understand what shes saying. This is ridiculous. And then shes just like, And these socialists that are ruining the country, theyd all be thrown in the gulag. Americans established power in legislative, executive, and judicial branches of government. So know, the leadership point is really important. A battle scene. To conduct investigation. If you had a plus twenty vote for secession, then Nashvilles coming along because it lost. Revolutions can be contagious. Success is one thing all of these revolutions have in common. It rejected European racist hierarchies and defined all Haitians as "black." they think they should take, and thats a compromise to them. towards conflict, towards division away from honesty, mean, just look at the Fox News revelations regarding the twenty twenty election, there is such an incredible pressure to conform with that Trumpist culture now that its just radiating up and down the rightward part of the spectrum. Everywhere the French went, they ended feudalism, promoted equal rights and religious tolerance, and modernized government administrations. However, there is a difference that makes the American revolution succeeded while the French revolution doesnt. The late 18th and 19th century brought about the French and Haitian Revolutions. Everyone, and welcome to the Focus Group podcast. Two revolutions, both taking place in the 18th Century, both world-changing. thanks so much for having me. Right. Articles from Britannica Encyclopedias for elementary and high school students. The government and leadership in France was corrupt as they were in much debt. The French justified their revolution by following the same principles as the colonists did. The Americans, in contrast, did not envy the British; they wanted to be left alone, to chart their own political destiny. And in Latin Americawell that wasn't so clear at the start. The leaders of the French Revolution were inspired by the American Revolution with its established representative democracy. They even briefly abolished slavery, which would have a strong effect in the French Caribbean colony of Saint Domingue. If the right wing media is your universe. What what did you make of how the group reacted? Marjorie Taylor Greene wants a national divorce. In 1810, peasants in Mexico revolted because they wanted their own land and because food prices were too high. Dont say it. But the republic was short-lived. The French Revolution, inspired by the American Revolution as well as the Enlightenment, freed French citizens from an absolute monarchy and secured equality before the law for all male citizens. The plantation system was dismantled, and Haiti became a nation of subsistence farmers who worked their own land. He managed to overcome internal resistance in the colony and outmaneuver foreign powers like the Spanish and British. And unsurprisingly, the next section I have here is, lets listen to these voters talk the media. There, they freed a handful of prisoners, seized weapons to defend the city, and beheaded two officials. The Declaration of Independence was basically announcing them as not the thirteen colonies but as the first thirteen states of the U.S. The leadership in both countries at the time of their revolutions was certainly repressive, especially in terms of taxation. He didnt threaten him. The American Revolution main aim was to gain independence from the British while the French revolutions main aim was to get rid of the French monarchy that was deemed corrupt. This is never gonna happen. While every effort has been made to follow citation style rules, there may be some discrepancies. He joins Sarah to talk about whether (and how) the United States holds together; and the task of rebuilding trust in our institutions. Many of the enlisted men were farm boys, as were most of the Americans. So all of the major social, political, cultural religious forces are pushing us apart into separate camps. Yes. This means that the French Revolution was a more recent event and was therefore influenced by the ideas and events of the American Revolution. I could not pick one person or institution individual that I would trust. You know, the mainstream media will call it out when the left messes up. like, thats too far. Shes never been conservative about anything. You know, get out the first and you wont be the last person to accuse me of polyamish thinking about people. Its what the media does to it. Yeah. was such a textbook example of countless conversations Ive had since late twenty fifteen, which is one of the responses people have to some of the most outrageous rhetoric on the right whether it comes from Trump or it comes from Marjorie Taylor Green or Matt Gates, or you name it, is they laugh. The French Revolution was a revolution fought between the peasants and nobility of France. They both got their idea from Enlightenment thinkers. The sad thing is though, as theyre laughing and I think they know this and this was hinted at in in the focus group. And now, would the Republican party be like that if Mitt Romney had won in twenty twelve and was running again in twenty sixteen. The Civil War was more than an unsatisfied party rebelling against a larger power, but a clash between two vastly different ways of life. Since it numbered only about 42,000, heavy recruiting programs were introduced. As a reminder, this should be a quick process! The American Revolution turned the American society into a republic, as the French Revolution eventually led the French society into dictatorship and more chaos in the, The American and French Revolution both had similar stages that a revolution consists of having a normal stage, widespread dissatisfaction, and the transfer of power and effect. Like, on a government building, that was unimaginable. It can happen. Sort of laughing at the excesses and not taking it incredibly seriously. Which one is most important in history when we aren't using the bias of America. And yet the most unbelievable things often comes out of their mouths. To log in and use all the features of Khan Academy, please enable JavaScript in your browser. Right. The Haitian Revolution established the second independent republic in the Americas and the first independent nation-state ruled by people of African descent. They take they take they take they keep taking rights away. Well, then I stand you know, more afraid. All revolutions have many stages which they go through, these three stages are the main bits of a, The American Revolution and the French Revolution have similar and different causes to their revolution. The fundamentals of each revolution, why the citizens were fighting are completely different. And people can do it for a while. From the top down, there is a cultural course that is set. If youre working in a McDonalds for a manager, if youre working in an in assurance company for the manager, you name it. The main difference between the American and French Revoultion was that one successfully converted to a democratic government and one did not. When electronic voting first started, I would go to my polling place in Tennessee and I would press the button and I would light up all of the people I was voting for, and then I would press vote. Like, the red states, blue states then they all have blue cities inside of red states, and we are all intermingled and also based on thanksgivings as best I can tell for gross people, you know, share these different political opinions and people that they love. We have seen media scandals. About living in a blue state. But now Im against it because we have to take care of our own people first. Shes not serious. And this is happening not just in the sense of you and your neighbor being pushed apart. But, as liberating as that sounds, Napoleon also enforced French values and authority with an iron fist. And and theyre theyre fighting. The democrats idea of compromise, for an example, undergone control. And when I drill down, I find out that they dont actually. Revolutionaries were inspired by the ideals of the Enlightenment including individual freedom. Which one of these revolutions was the greatest in relevance to the listing of mankind rights? I think shes just silly. get to us? We dont know anything about compromise. And Ive always liked this formulation that there was absolutely a recessive gene within the Republican party. Their idea of a compromise is well take only half of what we think we should take. They were swimming along with the course quite merrily. its what happened to you. Both revolutions were driven by a desire for greater freedom and equality, and both resulted in significant changes to the respective countries. The National Assembly ended the privileges of the nobles and ended feudalism in France. And so I do think there is no American institution that you just sort of say, well, whatever they say I take it, face value, for granted, theyre absolutely trustworthy. Colorful drawings of soldiers In different colored uniforms holding heads on pikes. People heavily associate the French Revolution with the American Revolution, due to the many general similarities. Republican Party to take on Donald Trump. The Haitian Revolution (1791-1808) was, more than any other, a social revolution for human rights and equality regardless of skin color. The officers were drawn largely from the gentry and the aristocracy and obtained their commissions and promotions by purchase. So David, heres my notice about these comments. Angry with the monarchys way of dealing with taxes, they wanted equal rights. Both revolutions followed the anatomy of a revolution and had comparable causes, however the French Revolution politically better outcomes, whereas the Latin American Revolution resulted in poverty and lost territory. But then theres this whole concept of manufactured distrust. The American and French Revolution are both remembered in history as two major changes that would shape what we know today. What is a revolution? And the answer is the one you feed. This document declared the sovereignty of the American states and listed the natural rights of mankind. Mhmm. The problem right now is that they listen to these people and I can see they take care of their families, they volunteer at dog shelters . INSTEAD OF A BLUE STATE. mean, when did Chris Ruffo become a traitor to the cause? And, you know, one of the things thats distressing is that this idea that, well, we know theres stream. For Britain, taxing their American colonies seemed like a great idea, but after such a long time of self-rule and near autonomy, the colonists in North America had ideas of their own. But then if you tell them about, say, the Seth Rich conspiracy theory coming out of Fox or all of the Dominion nonsense coming out of Fox, that doesnt tell them to distrust Fox. Shes wrong about everything. And so if youre talking about succession, what youre often talking about here, if youre looking at sort of historically, I mean, weve had various attempts. They write new content and verify and edit content received from contributors. Dont trust mail in and then Fox calls for Arizona, and the whole right wing population or much of it was like, wait, we were told not to trust this process, and theres Fox going ahead and calling this red state for Biden that cant possibly be real. Students complete an 11 item graphic organizer with 3 questions to compare and contrast the Revolutionary War and French Revolution. Painting of several large sailboats on a stormy sea. Well, centering, theres a lot of centering in media. John Locke an American enlightenment thinker thought people had natural rights and that government should have limited power. by. Like, this this is absolutely what would happen. And because when Fox called Arizona, the response was not. The French Revolution began in 1789 with the storming of the Bastille on July 14th. Yeah. However, there were also differences as far as political, economic and social causes were concerned. Theyre passive participants and commentators about events that theyre not in control of that theyre not gonna exert their will over one way or the other. But to me, actually, it was part of what was funny. New York Times opinion columnist David French (literally) wrote the book on a possible national divorce. But the point of the one you feed is that means its what theyre taking in. Just on point by point by point. The French Revolution was a fight between the french citizens and the french monarchy, seeking to overthrow the french king. A lot of people think this country has headed for a revolution. Dont trust mail in balloting. Mhmm. I am victimized by the politics here. And so thats sort of this core vision of pluralism. And the best federalist paper. In this unit, you examined the American and French Revolutions. And you just kinda go back to talking about SEC football, but. So James Madison wrote federalist number ten, which is the best federalist paper. And they said, well, we liked it because we voted and then we got a paper print out that showed exactly who we voted for to confirm And then that paper printout was what was actually scanned. The similarity between them is that the citizens in both countries, both faced the block of common economical development of the government. So explain that and why these voters might benefit from a more concrete understanding of pluralism. Other countries also supported the Americans, including the Spanish and Dutch, who declared war on Great Britain in 1779 and 1780. And lastly, the British stripped the Americans of their rights and exploited them for much of their own possessions. The English Civil War was a war between the Parliamentarians and Royalists in England. I I do wanna ask you a question when were when were done about whether or not your feelings have changed at all. The nation of Haiti formally declared its independence on January 1, 1804. Were being pushed apart on multiple fronts, including geographically, for example, that people are super clustering into very bright red, into very bright blue parts of the country. right now. Were clustering culturally. The Americans and French both had a normal stage in which they were ruled by and monarchs were chosen in a traditional way. Our focus grew to have some thoughts. It tells you an awful lot. pulls his name out of the app, a lot of those investigations will automatically disappear. The French populace was divided into three estates. Thats what she spends all her time doing, and she knits them sweaters and all that stuff. Meanwhile, the Netherlands, which provided both official recognition of the United States and financial support for it, was engaged in its own war against Britain. I wouldnt be surprised if it took another civil war, to be honest. But there has just been this relentless drumbeat, and then I wrote about this for the times. Intentionally lying. We dont, but we asked our focus groups about it anyway. When American colonists won independence from Great Britain in the Revolutionary War, the French, who participated in the war themselves, were both close allies and key participants. But, like, We asked these Trump voters about the investigations into Trump and they dont think any of them are legitimate and they cant name anyone they would trust. And so I wonder if this is one of those things where people like over and besides how another set of people thinks about something, and the actual number of people who might want a national divorce is actually very small. And Ive said this to a million different people. The French Revolution took place in France from 1789-1799. What first sparked the American Revolution? first, and then I tend to hit CNN or MSN, and I try to read a lot of stories, I clearly cant trust our local papers anymore. Because the word exhausted. I mean, I guess you kinda need somebody like that on the team too, but you dont really put anything into it. Or if youre a typical Democrat, you believe that the average Republican is a lot more extreme than they are. Right? Both these revolutions had the similar cause, effects, and stages that resulted . We don't, but we asked our focus groups about it anyway. And in legalities. In North America, colonists fought off the British. The American Revolution was based on liberty, equality, and justice. I dont have the solution yet. The first two estates had many privileges while the Third Estate paid all the taxes and normally didn't have any voice in the government or in making laws. However, at the same time, and I actually wanna write about this, I think a lot of the folks who are saying, well, look, I mean, weve got blue cities and red states and got red areas and blue states. They continue to trust Fox. Is the role that leadership can play. The French were under a monarchy so the only option they had was to overthrow their king a create a republic. And you know, who does run the United States. The despot they had as a king was not treating everyone he ruled with fairness. Right? The similarity between them is that the citizens in both countries, both faced the block of common economical development of the government. Theyre not always accurate either. And so theres this absolute unwillingness to sort of say this is so far beyond the pale that Im gonna break with this kind of core sense of identity that I have. Theyre looking at all this toxic mess. So was he living up to his ideals? Were telling everybody dont trust mail in balloting. They were also similar because they both had social inequalities which was basically if you were in a different social class you were treated differently. This is a guy whos a slave owner. We should be able to get along. I do think that movements can be learning organisms. Right? So this is my last question for you. And look, people are responsible for their own choices about the news that they consume. What do you think? Number two, theres a minimization of whats negative about Trump or the Trumpist movement. However, over time divisions of opinion became apparent between federalists and anti-federalists. People have asked me a million times, why did so many evangelicals vote for the Trump? This coincides with James Otiss phrase, taxation without representation is tyranny, which led to, no taxation without representation. Enlightened thinkers such as Locke gave the ideas that it was the government's job to protect the people life, liberty, and property.These enlightened thinkers. Britain did this primarily by imposing a series of deeply unpopular laws and taxes, including the Sugar Act (1764), the Stamp Act (1765), and the so-called Intolerable Acts (1774). Understandably, the other European monarchs were pretty shocked. Many states continued to combine church and state. Direct link to layladuran.2007's post What factors led to the A, Posted 10 months ago. The bad news is the term for that group of people is the exhausted majority. A lot of the critique of the Trump era are going to be mystifying to you. And, like, sometimes people end up. These countries shared the same idea of freedom and independence, the difference is they used different methods of accomplishing this goal. First, I. think Fox is probably the most down the middle of any of them. Why? The American and French Revolutions differ more than just location and language. Also the American colonies had an army of trained officials led by George Washington, to fight against the British. And again, Sarah, I wanna underlying something you said earlier. Both of the revolutions were liberating, but the French revolution was more violent and bloodier than the American. It was hard. Both revolutions were connected to each other because of the link between France and Haiti, known then as St Domingue. But okay. Every child learns of the American Revolution at least once in their lives. This enraged the mob sparking the flame for the French. This is where Right. A powerful and popular general named Napoleon Bonaparte soon rose to power and declared himself emperor in 1799. Theres just no question about that. And I just heard this for years with Trump. So prior to the election, Fox and Trump, both of them, and you can go back and you can see the clips and read the reports. There always has been this sort of populist mainly white working class populist part of American politics, whatever it is, fifteen percent of America, twenty percent of America, and Trump tapped into that group pretty decisively. People are really angry or whatever. Both revolutions were caused, in one way or another, by taxes. Just Its been built into the right through the cold war, through Romney telling Obama that Russia is our chief geopolitical foe. You can throw put any ballots you want it to a box and then watch who count them. Jos de San Martnanother liberal revolutionaryled a revolt against the Spanish in southern Latin America. Its. Civil war seems, you know. Do you think its fair to say that those ideas caused these revolutions? Now well see. Ron DeSantis is what I talk about when its manufactured, distressed. However, there is a difference that makes the American revolution succeeded while the French revolution doesnt. They dont give. And I dont know enough about them to know if theyre trustworthy or not either. Revolutionary leaders established new countries that only sometimes lived up to promises of democratic rule. Though each of these revolutions had its own origins, important figures, and results, they were all tied together by three things. In June, the Third Estate met alone and declared itself the National Assembly. Which is the correct description of a revolution and one of its outcomes? So you and I are both big fans of a group called Warren Common. Well. Good standing. I mean, I live in California I wanna leave California. They do not like Trump. It was a bloody battle between the Mexican people and people who were loyal to Spain. For example, during the American Revolution the British 13 original American colonies were fighting for their independence against Great Britain. Fill out the Skimming for Gist section of the Three Close Reads Worksheet as you complete your first close read. And one of my big concerns is The minority of Americans who are extremely activated politically are extremely polarized and hate each other very much. A cause of the American revolution was taxation without representation. What classes took power in South America, and how was this different from the class that took power in Saint Domingue? Taxation without representation is tyranny, James Otis reportedly said in protest of the lack of colonial representation in Parliament. And now you can talk, but Im so bad about this. These are folks that if you met them in any other context, and were talking about any other topic, youd find them to be some of the best, most down to earth people that youd meet often. Bolvar had the support of the relatively new nation of Haiti, and he visited that country twice. In the early nineteenth century, some Latin American revolutionaries wanted exactly that. I mean, there were people who said, and I hear this all the time, or was like, look, as long as they got an r by their name, like, Im gonna wait for them. I dont understand. Thats who I wanna talk to. The debt from this huge war helped spark the American and French Revolutions. I just think shes like the AOC on the left side. With tension building between the two powers, the revolution was a battle that formed what America is today. All revolutions have many stages which they go through, these three stages are the main bits of a. Its not a one-sided problem. (7) $2.00.